Reviewer Guidelines

Presentation

The manuscript presents a coherent and logically structured argument, with ideas that are clearly articulated and easy to follow.

Writing

The title accurately reflects the content of the manuscript, and the writing is clear, concise, and easy to understand throughout the paper.

Length

The length of each section is appropriate, with clear identification of parts that may require expansion, reduction, condensation, summarization, or integration with other sections.

Title

The title is concise and informative, avoids implicit or redundant terms, and clearly represents the main finding or conclusion of the study. Abbreviations are not used in the title.

Abstract

The abstract clearly includes:

  1. the aim of the study;

  2. the research method;

  3. the main results or findings; and

  4. the conclusion.

Introduction

The Introduction clearly and systematically presents:

  • the background of the study;

  • relevant and up-to-date literature establishing the state of the art;

  • a clear gap analysis and statement of novelty;

  • the research problem or hypothesis, where applicable;

  • the general approach used to address the problem; and

  • the aim of the study.

Method

The methodology is described in sufficient detail to enable replication by other researchers.
The section explains not only key concepts but also the research procedures.
The research setting, participants, instruments, and data analysis techniques are clearly specified.

Results and Discussion

The results are presented in processed form, such as tables or figures, rather than raw data, and are supported by clear and logical explanations.
The findings directly address the research questions or objectives stated in the Introduction.
The discussion relates the results to previous studies, highlighting similarities or differences.
Each finding is interpreted scientifically and logically.
The implications of the findings are clearly discussed.
The limitations of the study or methodological constraints are acknowledged.
Suggestions for future research or further development of the topic are provided.

Conclusion

The conclusion clearly addresses the research objectives and, where appropriate, presents implications or recommendations.
The section is written as a coherent paragraph rather than in bullet points or numbered lists.